You are the EMS Medical Director reviewing a flagged QI case: a paramedic administered double-dose epinephrine during a cardiac arrest due to a LASA medication storage error. Navigate the investigation, root cause analysis, just culture corrective action, system redesign, reporting obligations, and 90-day follow-up audit.
You are the EMS Medical Director for a county EMS agency. Your QI coordinator has flagged a case for your review. A complaint was received from a receiving emergency physician regarding a prehospital care report (PCR) that documented a significant protocol deviation.
Case Summary:
- Incident: Cardiac arrest, residential, 2:47 AM
- Unit: Medic 7 (2-provider ALS unit)
- Crew: Alex Morgan (lead, 6 years experience) and Jordan Lee (partner, 2 years experience)
- Patient: 54-year-old male, found unresponsive by wife, unknown downtime
The receiving physician's concern: "The PCR documents epinephrine administered at 2 mg IV push (double the standard dose) for the first dose. The patient arrived in PEA with no ROSC. I need to know if this was intentional and what your agency's protocol says."
Your task: Review the PCR, identify the deviation, determine its clinical significance, and select the appropriate corrective action.
You review the PCR. Key documented findings:
Scene: Residential, 2:47 AM. Wife called 911 after finding husband unresponsive in bed. Last known well: 11 PM. The arrest time and duration without circulation are unknown.
Initial assessment: Unresponsive, apneic, pulseless. CPR initiated by wife (quality unknown). AED applied by fire first responders — no shock advised (asystole).
Rhythm: Asystole on arrival, converted to PEA (rate 40) after 8 minutes of CPR.
Airway: Supraglottic airway placed at 6 minutes. Waveform capnography confirmed.
Medications documented:
- 02:52 — Epinephrine 2 mg IV push (Alex Morgan)
- 02:57 — Epinephrine 1 mg IV push (Alex Morgan)
- 03:02 — Epinephrine 1 mg IV push (Alex Morgan)
- 03:05 — Amiodarone 300 mg IV push (Alex Morgan) ⚠️ *Note: Amiodarone is indicated for shock-refractory VF/pVT only — this patient was in asystole/PEA throughout. This represents a second potential protocol deviation.*
CPR quality: No ETCO2 values documented. No CPR feedback device documented.
Transport: Initiated at 03:08 (21 minutes on scene). Patient arrived in PEA, no ROSC.
Agency protocol for cardiac arrest: Epinephrine 1 mg IV/IO q3–5 minutes. Standard AHA ACLS algorithm.
Deviation identified: First epinephrine dose was 2 mg (double the protocol dose of 1 mg).
The first epinephrine dose was 2 mg instead of the protocol-specified 1 mg. How do you classify the clinical significance of this deviation?
Choose your answer to see the feedback. The rest of the case, the scored debrief and the Virtual FTO review come with a subscription.
Written and reviewed by Chester Shermer, MD, FACEP, board-certified emergency physician and HEMS medical director.