Medical Director — Underperforming Paramedic: Competency Review and Provider Wellness

Manage a chronically underperforming paramedic through progressive discipline. Navigate a PTSD and alcohol use disclosure during the PIP meeting, balance patient safety with compassionate support, and implement a system-wide wellness program.

The call

SCENARIO — Underperforming Paramedic: Progressive Discipline

You are the EMS Medical Director for a county EMS agency.

Background: Derek Nguyen, a 3-year provider, has been flagged in QA review. His QA coordinator presents the following data over the past 12 months:

QA Flags — Derek Nguyen:
- 8 PCR documentation deficiencies (incomplete assessments, missing vital signs)
- 3 medication errors (wrong dose — all caught before patient harm)
- 2 protocol deviations (failed to obtain 12-lead ECG on chest pain patients)
- 1 patient complaint: "The paramedic seemed distracted and didn't explain what he was doing"
- Peer feedback: "Derek seems disengaged. He rushes through assessments."

Comparison to peers: Average QA flags per provider per year: 1.2. Derek Nguyen: 14 flags.

Prior actions:
- 6 months ago: Informal counseling by shift supervisor (verbal)
- 3 months ago: Written warning for documentation deficiencies

The written warning did not result in improvement. You must now decide on the next step.

Decision 1 of 3: Decision 1: Next Step in Progressive Discipline

Derek Nguyen has 14 QA flags in 12 months against a peer average of 1.2, including 3 medication dosing errors caught before harm and 2 missed 12-lead ECGs on chest pain patients. Informal counseling and a written warning produced no improvement. What is your next step?

  1. Keep his current clinical duties and shift schedule and arrange an unpaid suspension hearing with the clinician, supervisor and HR
  2. Assess immediate safety needs and arrange an unpaid suspension hearing with the clinician, supervisor and HR
  3. Assess immediate safety needs and arrange a formal competency and performance review with the clinician, supervisor and HR
  4. Keep his current clinical duties and shift schedule and arrange a formal competency and performance review with the clinician, supervisor and HR

Choose your answer to see the feedback. The rest of the case, the scored debrief and the Virtual FTO review come with a subscription.

Written and reviewed by Chester Shermer, MD, FACEP, board-certified emergency physician and HEMS medical director.

See plans · Play a full scenario free · All scenarios