Medical Director — Scope of Practice Violation: Life-Saving Surgical Cricothyrotomy

A paramedic performs a surgical cricothyrotomy outside her credentialed scope of practice during a true CICO emergency. The patient survives. Navigate the credentialing decision, disciplinary response, and policy development that balances accountability with the realities of emergency medicine.

The call

SCENARIO — Scope of Practice Violation and Credentialing Decision

You are the EMS Medical Director for a county EMS agency.

Situation: Your QA coordinator flags a PCR from last Tuesday. Anita Patel performed a surgical cricothyrotomy on a 34-year-old male trauma patient with a failed airway (can't intubate, can't oxygenate scenario).

The facts:
- Patient: 34M, MVC, facial trauma, failed RSI x2, SpO2 dropping to 72% despite suction, repositioning, airway adjuncts, an optimized two-person bag-mask technique, and an attempted supraglottic rescue airway
- Anita Patel performed a surgical cric using a scalpel-finger-bougie technique
- Patient was successfully oxygenated and survived
- Surgical cricothyrotomy is NOT in the agency's paramedic scope of practice
- Anita Patel is credentialed for RSI but NOT for surgical airway
- Anita Patel received surgical airway training at a NAEMSP conference 6 months ago (personal initiative, not agency-sponsored; attendance alone does not establish current competency)

Anita Patel's statement: "I know it's not in our protocols. But the patient was going to die. I had the training and the equipment. I made the call."

The patient's family has sent a thank-you letter to the agency praising Anita Patel for "saving his life."

You must make a credentialing and disciplinary decision that balances patient safety, provider accountability, and the realities of emergency medicine.

Decision 1 of 3: Decision 1: Immediate Response to the Scope Violation

Anita Patel, credentialed for RSI but not for surgical airway, performed a scalpel-finger-bougie cricothyrotomy on a 34-year-old trauma patient after two failed RSI attempts, failed bag-mask and supraglottic rescue, and SpO2 falling to 72%. He survived and the family has sent thanks. What is your immediate response?

  1. Conduct a formal case review with your medical advisory committee and keep her current credentials unchanged
  2. Open a formal case review with the medical advisory committee and suspend her agency clinical credentials pending its outcome
  3. Close the case with a public letter of commendation and keep her current credentials unchanged
  4. Close the case with a public letter of commendation and expand her agency clinical credentials to include surgical cricothyrotomy

Choose your answer to see the feedback. The rest of the case, the scored debrief and the Virtual FTO review come with a subscription.

Written and reviewed by Chester Shermer, MD, FACEP, board-certified emergency physician and HEMS medical director.

See plans · Play a full scenario free · All scenarios