Medical Director — QA/QI: System-Wide Airway Management Failure

Analyze 6 months of declining intubation data, conduct a root cause analysis that reveals a protocol error you approved, implement a corrective action plan, and establish system-level safeguards to prevent future protocol failures.

The call

SCENARIO — QA/QI: Airway Management Trend Analysis

You are the EMS Medical Director for a county EMS agency (180 paramedics, 60 EMTs).

Situation: Your QA coordinator presents you with the monthly QA report. She flags a concerning trend:

Data from the past 6 months:
| Month | RSI Cases | First-Pass Success (number/denominator) | Unrecognized Esophageal Intubations | Hypoxia Events (SpO2 <90% during intubation) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan | 42 | 33/42 (78.6%) | 0 | 4 |
| Feb | 38 | 29/38 (76.3%) | 1 | 6 |
| Mar | 45 | 32/45 (71.1%) | 0 | 8 |
| Apr | 41 | 28/41 (68.3%) | 2 | 11 |
| May | 39 | 25/39 (64.1%) | 1 | 14 |
| Jun | 44 | 27/44 (61.4%) | 2 | 17 |

Agency improvement targets:
- First-pass success rate: Local target ≥85%
- Unrecognized esophageal intubations: Target = 0
- Hypoxia events during intubation: Target <5%

QA Coordinator: "The trend is clearly worsening. We've had 6 unrecognized esophageal intubations in 6 months. Three of those patients died. Hypoxia rose from 4/42 cases (9.5%) to 17/44 (38.6%), approximately fourfold. I don't know what's causing it but something has changed."

You must investigate, identify root causes, and implement a corrective action plan.

Decision 1 of 3: Decision 1: Root Cause Investigation

Over 6 months, first-pass success fell from 78.6% to 61.4%, hypoxia during intubation rose from 4 of 42 to 17 of 44 cases, and 6 esophageal intubations went unrecognized, with 3 deaths. The cause is not yet known. What is your first step in the root cause investigation?

  1. Begin individual event and system review and send all paramedics a bulletin to verify tube placement by capnography
  2. Begin individual event and system review while putting immediate airway safety measures in place
  3. Review the six intubating paramedics' cases and remediate each one while putting immediate airway safety measures in place
  4. Review the six intubating paramedics' cases and send each one a bulletin to verify tube placement by capnography

Choose your answer to see the feedback. The rest of the case, the scored debrief and the Virtual FTO review come with a subscription.

Written and reviewed by Chester Shermer, MD, FACEP, board-certified emergency physician and HEMS medical director.

See plans · Play a full scenario free · All scenarios