Medical Director — Patient Complaint and Media Inquiry: Alleged Negligent Care

Manage a simultaneous patient complaint, attorney letter, media inquiry, and distressed crew after a cardiac arrest death. Investigate the call, craft a legally sound media response, support the crew through second victim syndrome, and meet with the family.

The call

SCENARIO — Patient Complaint and Media Inquiry: Alleged Negligent Care

You are the EMS Medical Director for a county EMS agency.

Monday, 0900: Your administrative assistant forwards an email from a local news reporter:

*"Doctor, I'm investigating a story about an EMS response on March 14th. A 54-year-old man suffered a cardiac arrest. His spouse alleges that the paramedics arrived 18 minutes after the call, did not perform CPR correctly, and refused to transport him to the hospital of her choice. The patient died. The patient's spouse has filed a formal complaint with your agency. I would like your comment for a story running Thursday. — a local reporter"*

Simultaneously, you receive:
1. A formal complaint letter from an attorney representing the patient's spouse
2. A call from the agency director asking "what happened"
3. A call from the crew involved — Paramedics Torres and Williams — who are "devastated and want to talk"

You have 72 hours before the news story runs. You must manage multiple simultaneous demands while conducting a proper investigation.

Decision 1 of 3: Decision 1: Immediate Priority

It is Monday 0900. A reporter wants your comment for a Thursday story on a March 14 cardiac arrest death. The spouse's attorney has sent a formal complaint, the agency director is asking what happened, and Paramedics Torres and Williams are devastated and want to talk. What is your first action?

  1. Interview Torres and Williams today while telling the reporter the crew met standards and offering prompt support
  2. Preserve and review PCR and dispatch evidence while coordinating a privacy-safe acknowledgment and prompt crew support
  3. Interview Torres and Williams today while coordinating a privacy-safe acknowledgment and prompt crew support
  4. Preserve and review PCR and dispatch evidence while telling the reporter the crew met standards and offering prompt support

Choose your answer to see the feedback. The rest of the case, the scored debrief and the Virtual FTO review come with a subscription.

Written and reviewed by Chester Shermer, MD, FACEP, board-certified emergency physician and HEMS medical director.

See plans · Play a full scenario free · All scenarios