Medical Director — New Protocol Implementation: Managing Resistance and System Change

Implement a new evidence-informed STEMI protocol over resistance from cardiologists, senior paramedics, and the union. Navigate evidence-based negotiation, change management, and labor relations to shorten first-medical-contact-to-device times.

The call

SCENARIO — New Protocol Implementation: Managing Resistance and System Change

You are the EMS Medical Director for a regional EMS agency (220 providers, 3 stations).

Situation: You want to implement an updated ACS/STEMI care pathway aligned with current evidence and national guidance.

Proposed Protocol Changes:
1. Early 12-lead ECG acquisition and transmission to the receiving facility as soon as feasible (target within 10 minutes of first medical contact when system conditions allow)
2. Aspirin 162–325 mg chewable PO for suspected ACS, if no contraindications (updates fixed-dose approach)
3. EMS-facilitated cath lab activation by field paramedics using validated criteria and locally approved processes, introduced via a time-limited pilot with quality review (with real-time consultation available when needed)
4. Competency-based 12-lead interpretation training and verification for all ALS providers before activation authority

Evidence base: Contemporary ACS guidance and NAEMSP statements support early ECG, timely reperfusion pathways, and system-level processes to reduce reperfusion delays. Multiple peer-reviewed studies show EMS-initiated activation can safely shorten time-to-reperfusion in many systems when paired with training, clear criteria, and robust QA. Local validation and stakeholder agreement are essential; you plan a pilot with predefined metrics and regular review.

Resistance you've encountered:
- Cardiologists at the receiving hospital: "Paramedics shouldn't be activating the cath lab — too many false positives"
- Senior paramedics: "We've been doing it the old way for 20 years. Why change?"
- Training officer: "We don't have the budget for new training"
- Union: "This is a scope expansion — requires renegotiation of the collective bargaining agreement"

You must navigate this resistance to implement a protocol that improves patient outcomes.

Decision 1 of 3: Decision 1: Responding to Cardiologist Resistance

The cardiologists argue that paramedic-activated cath lab will result in too many false positives and wasted resources. How do you respond?

  1. Present balanced evidence and propose a collaborative, time-limited pilot with jointly defined metrics (activation accuracy, key time intervals, resource use, and outcomes), paired with targeted training and scheduled case reviews
  2. Abandon the cath lab activation component and keep physician authorization while implementing the other changes
  3. Invoke your authority and implement unilaterally

Choose your answer to see the feedback. The rest of the case, the scored debrief and the Virtual FTO review come with a subscription.

Written and reviewed by Chester Shermer, MD, FACEP, board-certified emergency physician and HEMS medical director.

See plans · Play a full scenario free · All scenarios