Medical Director — Impaired Clinician: Suspected Substance Use on Duty

Navigate the discovery of a potentially impaired paramedic on duty. Make immediate patient safety decisions, manage the fitness-for-duty evaluation process, fulfill mandatory reporting requirements, and address the culture of non-reporting among colleagues.

The call

SCENARIO — Impaired Clinician: Suspected Substance Use on Duty

You are the EMS Medical Director for a county EMS agency.

Situation: It is 0630 on a Saturday morning. You receive a call from the overnight shift supervisor, Lt. Martinez. She states: "Dr. Chen, I need to speak with you urgently. I have a paramedic, James Holloway — 8-year veteran, excellent record — who I believe may be impaired. He's been acting strange all shift. Slurred speech, unsteady gait, and a patient's family member just called and complained that he smelled of alcohol during a call at 0400."

Background on James Holloway:
- 8-year paramedic, no prior disciplinary history
- Recently divorced (known personal stressors)
- Missed 3 shifts in the past 6 weeks (called in sick)
- Currently on duty, has 2 hours remaining in his shift
- His partner, Sarah Kim, has not formally reported anything but "seems uncomfortable"

Lt. Martinez: "He's in the station right now. I haven't confronted him yet. I wanted to call you first. What do you want me to do?"

You must make several critical decisions as Medical Director.

Decision 1 of 3: Decision 1: Immediate Action

Lt. Martinez is on the phone at 0630. James Holloway is in the station with 2 hours left in his shift. She has seen slurred speech and an unsteady gait all shift, and a patient's family member called to report that he smelled of alcohol on a 0400 call. She has not spoken to him yet. What is your immediate instruction?

  1. Remove him from patient care and driving, and send him for reasonable-suspicion alcohol testing
  2. Keep him on the unit until shift end, then arrange a medical assessment and a fitness-for-duty evaluation
  3. Remove him from patient care and driving, arrange a medical assessment, and start a fitness-for-duty evaluation
  4. Have him questioned privately, keep him on the unit until shift end, then send him for reasonable-suspicion alcohol testing

Choose your answer to see the feedback. The rest of the case, the scored debrief and the Virtual FTO review come with a subscription.

Written and reviewed by Chester Shermer, MD, FACEP, board-certified emergency physician and HEMS medical director.

See plans · Play a full scenario free · All scenarios