Field Termination of Resuscitation — Medical Director Case Review

You are the EMS Medical Director reviewing a flagged case: a cardiac arrest patient meeting all ALS TOR criteria was transported to the ED after an OLMC physician authorized transport based on family request alone. Navigate TOR criteria assessment, OLMC accountability, crew evaluation, family communication protocol gaps, protocol updates, and physician complaint response.

The call

CASE REVIEW — Field Termination of Resuscitation

You are the EMS Medical Director for a county EMS agency. Your QI coordinator has flagged a case for your review. A receiving emergency physician has filed a complaint stating that a cardiac arrest patient was transported against protocol and arrived in asystole, and questions the transport decision.

Case Summary:
- Incident: Out-of-hospital cardiac arrest, residential
- Unit: Medic 12 (2-paramedic ALS unit)
- Crew: Chris Lane (lead, 4 years experience) and Dana Reed (partner, 8 years experience)
- Patient: 72-year-old male, found unresponsive by wife

The receiving physician's complaint: "This patient met every TOR criterion. He was transported for no clinical reason, arrived in asystole after 45 minutes of resuscitation, and the family had to watch him die in the ED. The crew should have terminated in the field. What is your agency's TOR protocol and why wasn't it followed?"

Your task: Review the PCR, evaluate TOR criteria application, assess the crew's decision-making, determine appropriate corrective action, and address family communication standards.

PCR Review

You review the PCR. Key documented findings:

Scene: Residential, 11:43 PM. Wife called 911 after finding husband unresponsive in bed. Last known well: 10:30 PM. Arrest was unwitnessed; actual arrest time and no-flow interval are unknown.

Initial assessment: Unresponsive, apneic, pulseless. No bystander CPR. AED applied by fire first responders at 11:51 PM — no shock advised (asystole).

EMS arrival: 11:54 PM. Asystole confirmed on monitor.

Resuscitation timeline:
- 11:54 — CPR initiated, IV access established
- 11:56 — Epinephrine 1 mg IV
- 11:58 — Advanced airway (supraglottic airway), waveform capnography confirmed
- 12:01 — Epinephrine 1 mg IV
- 12:06 — Epinephrine 1 mg IV (12 minutes of ALS resuscitation)
- 12:11 — Epinephrine 1 mg IV (17 minutes of ALS resuscitation)
- 12:16 — Rhythm check: Asystole. No ROSC. No shockable rhythm at any point.
- 12:18 — Chris Lane contacts OLMC: "We have a 72-year-old male, asystole, 24 minutes of ALS, no ROSC, no shockable rhythm. Requesting TOR."
- 12:18 — OLMC physician: "Transport — family is requesting transport."
- 12:19 — Transport initiated.
- 12:39 — Arrival at ED. Asystole. No ROSC. ED physician pronounces death.

TOR rules and the agency's local protocol:
- AHA 2025 BLS/universal rule: Arrest not witnessed by EMS; no ROSC before transport; no AED shock before transport.
- AHA 2025 ALS rule: Unwitnessed arrest; no bystander CPR; no ROSC before transport; no shock before transport.
- Meeting a rule supports considering termination in its validated setting; it does not mandate stopping or replace assessment of reversible/special circumstances.
- This agency additionally requires at least 20 minutes of ALS, OLMC authorization and review of exceptions. That local duration is not a universal AHA threshold.

At 12:16 AM, 22 minutes of ALS have elapsed. At the 12:18 AM call, 24 minutes have elapsed. The documented features meet the ALS rule and this case's duration requirement, so a TOR discussion is appropriate.

Decision 1 of 6: DECISION POINT — TOR Criteria Assessment

At the 12:18 AM OLMC call, do the documented findings support consideration of TOR under this agency's ALS protocol?

  1. No — the clock starts at advanced-airway placement (11:58 PM), so the minimum was not met.
  2. Yes — the arrest was unwitnessed, with no bystander CPR, shock or ROSC, and 24 minutes of ALS completed
  3. No — an unknown downtime prevents any TOR consideration
  4. No — the wife was present and requested transport, which overrides TOR criteria

Choose your answer to see the feedback. The rest of the case, the scored debrief and the Virtual FTO review come with a subscription.

Written and reviewed by Chester Shermer, MD, FACEP, board-certified emergency physician and HEMS medical director.

See plans · Play a full scenario free · All scenarios